Every second paragraph in my current stack opens with “Another theme in Macbeth is ambition.” Thank you, I had noticed. What actually works for getting students to write topic sentences that make an argument?
I was absolutely that student two years ago, so maybe the view from the other side helps.
What changed it for me was a seminar leader who gave us a three-part formula: claim, how, and so what. The claim says something debatable, the how points to the evidence the paragraph will use, and the so what links it back to the thesis. It sounds mechanical, but it forced me to decide what I actually thought before I started writing the paragraph.
My before and after on Macbeth, from an actual essay:
Before: “Another theme in Macbeth is ambition.”
After: “Macbeth’s ambition only becomes murderous once Lady Macbeth recasts it as a test of his manhood, which suggests the play locates the danger less in desire itself than in the way others weaponize it.”
The second one is longer and a bit clunky, but my marker wrote “now we’re talking” next to it, and the paragraph underneath was far better because I knew what it had to prove. I think a lot of students write the announcing version because they genuinely haven’t figured out their point yet, and the formula exposes that gently.
I taught secondary English for thirty-one years, and I’d say about half of my working life was spent on exactly this. The lovely thing is that it’s very fixable once students see the difference for themselves.
Two quick tests I gave every class:
-
The disagreement test. Could a sensible reader disagree with this sentence? “Ambition is a theme in Macbeth” passes no one’s disagreement test. “Macbeth is less ambitious than he is suggestible” does, and that’s what makes it worth a paragraph.
-
The because test. Can you add “because” to the end of the sentence and keep going? If the sentence is an argument, there’s a reason behind it waiting to be written. If it’s a topic, “because” leads nowhere.
The exercise that did the most good was one I stumbled into by accident. I photocopied student paragraphs, blanked out the first sentence, and swapped them around the room. Each student had to read someone else’s paragraph and write the topic sentence it deserved. Two things happened. Students realized the evidence in their paragraphs was often making a sharper point than their opening sentence admitted. And they started to see the topic sentence as the conclusion of the paragraph’s thinking, written at the top, rather than a label.
I also asked them to write topic sentences last, after drafting the paragraph. That felt backwards to some of them, but it’s how most good writers actually work. You find out what you think by writing it, then you go back and lead with it.
@book_nadia’s formula is a good one for the drafting stage. I’d only add that the “so what” can come later in the paragraph if cramming it into the first sentence makes it unreadable. Your students sound like they’re nearly there, Lucia. Announcing a theme at least shows they’ve found one.
The most useful framing I know comes from Joseph Williams, whose Style: Lessons in Clarity and Grace distinguishes the issue of a paragraph (its opening, which frames what follows) from its point (the claim the rest of the paragraph supports). Williams argues that readers look for the point at the end of the issue, and they read the rest of the paragraph in light of it. “Another theme is ambition” gives readers an issue with no point, so they have nothing to test the evidence against. That’s why such paragraphs feel like lists even when the quotations are good.
Graff and Birkenstein’s They Say / I Say approaches the same problem from another angle: a claim gets its force from what it pushes against. A topic sentence becomes argumentative almost automatically when it implies a view it’s rejecting. “Although Macbeth is usually read as a study of ambition, the play is more interested in how quickly ambition becomes fear” has a built-in opponent and therefore a built-in argument.
Putting those together, here’s what I’d teach:
- Write the thesis first. Each topic sentence should be a sub-claim the thesis needs, not a new topic.
- Give each topic sentence a verb that does analytical work: exposes, complicates, undermines, displaces. “Is” and “shows” are where announcements hide.
- Name the evidence domain in the sentence (the dagger soliloquy, the banquet scene, the sleepwalking scene) so the reader knows what kind of proof is coming.
- Reverse outline the draft: copy only the topic sentences into a list and read them in order. If they make an argument on their own, the essay has one. If they read like a table of contents, it doesn’t.
A worked example. Thesis: Macbeth presents ambition as self-consuming, because each act meant to secure Macbeth’s position produces new fear. Topic sentences:
- The dagger soliloquy shows Macbeth’s ambition already shading into hallucination before he has acted.
- Banquo’s murder, intended to end Macbeth’s fear, instead multiplies it, as the banquet scene’s ghost makes public.
- By the sleepwalking scene, the ambition that drove Lady Macbeth has collapsed entirely into guilt, completing the play’s argument that ambition cannot rest.
Read in sequence, those three sentences are an essay in miniature. That reverse-outline check is the single most effective revision exercise I’ve seen, and students can do it on their own drafts in five minutes. @lina_760’s blanked-paragraph exercise is the perfect warm-up for it.
I agree with the reverse outline that @theo_reads describes, but I would offer two qualifications, because overcorrection is also common.
First, a topic sentence need not carry the entire paragraph. Some students, once told to argue, produce opening sentences of sixty words that contain the claim, all of the evidence and the conclusion. The paragraph that follows then has nothing left to do. A topic sentence should state the claim and indicate the direction of proof; the proof itself belongs in the body.
Second, the topic sentence is not always the first sentence. A paragraph may open with a transitional sentence that connects it to the previous one, and place the claim second. For example: “The banquet scene seems at first to restore order. In fact, it marks the moment Macbeth’s fear becomes visible to the entire court.” The second sentence is the topic sentence, and the first prepares it. Students who understand this produce more fluent essays than those who treat the first sentence as a slot to be filled.
There is research behind @the_nikolai’s second point. Richard Braddock’s 1974 study of professional essays published in magazines such as The Atlantic and Harper’s found that only a small minority of paragraphs actually opened with a simple, explicit topic sentence. Many paragraphs had their main claim in the middle or end, and some implied it without stating it at all.
That does not mean we should stop teaching topic sentences. It means we should present them as a tool for clarity rather than a law of nature. For student essays, where markers need to follow an argument quickly, an explicit claim near the start of each paragraph is usually the right choice. But students who later read published criticism should not be surprised to find that skilled writers bend the rule.
@lit_yusuf, I know the Braddock study and I think it’s often over-applied to student writing. Professional essayists in magazines are writing for readers who chose to read them; student essays are read by a marker working through a rubric. Most university marking criteria I have seen (and I have collected a fair number for our library’s writing guides) reward clarity of argument at the paragraph level explicitly. An implied claim is a risk a student can take later.
One concrete addition to @theo_reads’s verb list: give students a bank of verbs that encode a relationship rather than a fact. Complicates, qualifies, reverses, anticipates, parodies, exposes. A student who writes “The Porter scene parodies the play’s earlier treatment of damnation” has been forced, by the verb alone, to compare two parts of the play. The verb does half the teaching for you.
My contribution is a list of openers I’d quietly retire, compiled from roughly ten years of helping students in the library’s writing centre:
“Another theme in [text] is [noun].” The house special, as Lucia knows.
“In this paragraph I will discuss…” Thank you for the itinerary.
“Shakespeare uses many literary devices.” He did. That’s the job.
“Throughout the play, ambition is shown.” Shown by whom, to whom, and why should I care?
“This quote shows…” as the first words of a paragraph, which means the quote is in charge and the student isn’t.
The cure I’ve had the most luck with is making students say their topic sentence out loud to me before they write it. People who will happily write “another theme is ambition” become strangely embarrassed saying it to another adult’s face. Then they try again and usually produce something like “Macbeth’s ambition seems to belong more to his wife than to him”, which is wrong in places, debatable, and therefore a real start.
@anovak’s verb bank is a good idea. I’d laminate it.
my son’s Lord of the Flies essay last spring had “Another theme in the novel is savagery” heading three paragraphs. I’m just a reader, so I asked the only question I could think of: what do you think Golding is saying about savagery? He thought for a second and said the boys don’t become savage, they were savage already and the island just stops them pretending. I told him to write that down instead.
His teacher underlined it and wrote “yes!” in the margin. It’s the same move @omar_bianchi describes: saying it aloud to someone made him commit to a claim. Often the argument is already there and just needs someone to ask for it.
I TA’d a first-year seminar last spring and tried a version of the reverse outline that @theo_reads describes, but read aloud. Each student read only their topic sentences, one after another, to their small group. The first student read “Another theme in Macbeth is ambition. Another theme in Macbeth is guilt. Another theme in Macbeth is the supernatural,” and the whole group burst out laughing, including him.
It worked better than any comment I could have written. Everyone heard instantly that the essay was a list. Within the hour, most of them had rewritten their topic sentences into actual claims, using @lina_760’s because test as a check.
So my answer to Lucia: make the announcing version audible. Students tolerate it on the page but almost never out loud.